Anne Marie Fahey went missing in 1996 and has never been found, though a man was tried for and convicted of her murder.
Technically the case of Fahey’s disappearance has been solved, but her body was never found.
Fahey was 30 years old at the time of her disappearance. Three years later, in 1999, her boyfriend, married lawyer Thomas Capano, was found guilty of her murder. According to Delaware Online, Capano shot Fahey while she tried to break up with him then dumped her body in the Atlantic Ocean, having put it in a cooler.
Both of Capano’s brothers admitted they helped him get rid of the evidence, one of them even helping him to get rid of the body itself, according to Delaware Online. They both ultimately testified against him. Another one of Capono’s girlfriend’s admitted to buying him a gun.
Capano was convicted and sentenced to death, which was later overturned and converted to life in prison. He died in 2011.